Enter your nightly rate, occupancy and what a tenant would pay. See the net each way, the gap, and the occupancy and rate where Airbnb matches the lease.
No account needed·Free PDF report
Net per year, each wayExample
Long-term tenant$2,677Long-term net
Airbnb$6,705Airbnb net
Airbnb ahead by $4,028
Examples computed by this calculator on sample inputs. Not market data.
No account needed
Airbnb fees per Help Center article 1857
Every formula shown, sources dated
Free PDF report with every chart
How it works
Three steps. About a minute.
1
Step 1: Enter both plans
Your nightly rate and occupancy, the rent a tenant would pay, and the costs each plan carries. Defaults are example inputs.
2
Step 2: Compare the net
Net per month and per year for Airbnb and for a tenant, after fees, cleaning, vacancy, running costs and the costs you pay either way.
3
Step 3: Find the break-even
See the occupancy and the nightly rate at which Airbnb matches the lease, then keep the PDF.
Your report
What you'll get
MagicBNB reportAirbnb vs long-term rental · 1 of 5
Net per year, each wayFrom the sample
Airbnb$6,705Net per year
Long-term tenant$2,677Net per year
THE HEADLINE
What each plan leaves you in a year
Net per year for Airbnb and for a tenant, after fees, cleaning, vacancy, running costs and the costs you pay either way. The winner and the gap, in dollars.
Airbnb net per year
Long-term net per year
The gap between them
MagicBNB reportAirbnb vs long-term rental · 2 of 5
Airbnb ahead of long-term by occupancyFrom the sample
-$20k-$10k$0$10k$20kBreak-even $0
30%40%50%60%70%80%
THE CROSSING
The occupancy where Airbnb matches the lease
Below it the tenant wins, above it Airbnb does. Compare it with the occupancy you have really achieved.
Break-even occupancy
Airbnb net at each occupancy
The gap at each occupancy
MagicBNB reportAirbnb vs long-term rental · 3 of 5
Airbnb net at other nightly ratesFrom the sample
Nightly rateAirbnb net per yearAirbnb ahead by
$126-$3,621-$6,298
$153$1,542-$1,135
$180$6,705$4,028
$207$11,868$9,191
$234$17,031$14,354
THE RATE
The nightly rate that matches the tenant
Hold your occupancy and ask what rate Airbnb needs. If your rate is above it, Airbnb is ahead.
Break-even nightly rate
Airbnb net at other rates
The gap at each rate
MagicBNB reportAirbnb vs long-term rental · 4 of 5
Break-even at other tenant rentsFrom the sample
0%25%50%75%
45.6%
50.1%
54.7%
59.2%
63.7%
$1,760$1,980$2,200 (yours)$2,420$2,640
THE OFFER
How the bar moves with the rent on offer
A higher rent raises the occupancy and the rate Airbnb has to reach. Use it when a tenant makes an offer.
Break-even occupancy at each rent
Break-even rate at each rent
Your rent, marked
MagicBNB reportAirbnb vs long-term rental · 5 of 5
Revenue, host fee, cleaner, management, running costs, maintenance and shared costs for each plan, down to net per month and per year.
Costs only Airbnb carries
Costs only a tenant carries
Costs you pay either way
Showing part 1 of 5: Net each way
Net per month and per year, Airbnb against a tenant
The yearly gap between the two
Break-even occupancy and break-even nightly rate
Airbnb net at other occupancies and nightly rates
Break-even at other tenant rents
Lookup table
Airbnb against a tenant, by nightly rate and occupancy
Each cell is how many dollars a year Airbnb nets ahead of the long-term tenant (negative means the tenant is ahead), at that nightly rate and occupancy. Every other input is held at the sample values shown in the calculator above.
Airbnb net minus long-term net, per year
Nightly rate
Occupancy
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
$120
-$15,462
-$11,818
-$8,174
-$4,531
-$887
$150
-$11,761
-$7,192
-$2,623
$1,946
$6,515
$180
-$8,060
-$2,565
$2,929
$8,423
$13,917
$210
-$4,359
$2,061
$8,480
$14,900
$21,320
$240
-$658
$6,687
$14,032
$21,377
$28,722
Compare what is left, not what comes in
From the sample
Airbnb
Better here
Net a year
$6,705
Net a month
$559
Long-term tenant
Net a year
$2,677
Net a month
$223
Airbnb brings in far more revenue than rent, but it also carries the host fee, a cleaner for every stay, utilities, supplies and furnishing. A tenant brings in rent for the weeks it is let and costs maintenance.
The costs you pay either way, such as the mortgage and property tax, lower both nets by the same amount. So the fair test is net after every cost that differs between the two plans.
03
Mistakes this calculator catches
Airbnb looks bigger on revenue. These are the ways the comparison goes wrong once the costs are counted.
01Comparing revenue, not net
On the example inputs Airbnb brings in $47,200 a year against $24,877 of rent. After the host fee, cleaner, running costs and shared costs it nets $6,705 against $2,677, a much smaller gap.
02Forgetting the empty weeks
Three empty weeks between tenants cost $1,523 a year at $2,200 a month, so a tenant who is let all year nets more than the example shows. Enter your own figure.
03Using a hopeful occupancy
At 62% occupancy the example Airbnb is $4,028 ahead. At 45% it nets a loss of $2,636 and the tenant is ahead by $5,313. Use the occupancy you have achieved.
Break-even occupancy settles it
Airbnb ahead of long-term by occupancyFrom the sample
-$20k-$10k$0$10k$20k
-$13.6k
-$8.1k
-$2.6k
$2.9k
$8.4k
$13.9k
Break-even $0
30%40%50%60%70%80%
Airbnb net climbs in a straight line with occupancy, and the tenant net does not move. Where the two lines cross is the break-even occupancy: below it the tenant wins, above it Airbnb does.
Compare that figure with the occupancy you have really achieved, or a comparable listing's, rather than the occupancy you hope for.
The break-even nightly rate, at your occupancy
Net per year, each wayFrom the sample
$0$2k$4k$6k$8k
$6.7k
$2.7k
AirbnbLong-term tenant
The other way to read the same crossing: hold your occupancy and ask what nightly rate Airbnb needs. If your rate is already above it, Airbnb is ahead; if it is below, the tenant is.
MagicBNB's Property Detail view shows each property's month-by-month revenue, so you can see what your rate and occupancy really were before you compare.
How people use it
01
Owner with a tenant's offer
A tenant offers $2,800 a month and the owner is weighing it against listing on Airbnb.
Sees that on the example inputs Airbnb needs 67.0% occupancy to match, so the offer wins unless occupancy is higher.
02
Manager quoting an owner
Wants to show an owner both options with management fees on each: 20% on Airbnb and 8% on a lease.
Sees Airbnb net fall to a $1,442 loss and the lease net $687, with Airbnb needing 67.1% occupancy to catch up.
Airbnb or a long-term tenant, worked through
Is Airbnb or a long-term rental more profitable?
Whichever nets more after its own costs. On the example inputs Airbnb nets $6,705 a year and a tenant nets $2,677, so Airbnb is $4,028 ahead.
Compare net, not revenue. Airbnb brings in more, but it also pays the host fee, a cleaner for every stay, running costs and furnishing. A tenant brings in rent for the weeks it is let and costs maintenance.
The mortgage, property tax and standard insurance are the same either way. They move both nets by the same amount and do not change the gap.
$180 a night at 62% occupancy, against $2,200 a month
Airbnb226.3 nights x $180 = $40,734, plus 64.7 cleaning fees x $100 = $6,466, subtotal $47,200
Less host fee $7,316, cleaner $5,819, running costs $6,360, shared costs $21,000$6,705 net
Tenant$2,200 x 12 x 49/52 = $24,877, less maintenance $1,200 and shared costs $21,000: $2,677 net
Airbnb ahead by $4,028 a year
What occupancy does Airbnb need to beat a tenant?
The break-even occupancy. On the example inputs it is 54.7%.
Airbnb net rises in a straight line with occupancy, so the break-even is the occupancy at which that line meets the tenant net.
Compare it with an occupancy you have really achieved or a comparable listing's, not a best month.
Break-even occupancy on the example inputs
Tenant net $2,677 plus running costs $6,360 plus shared costs $21,000$30,037 the bookings must earn
At 62% occupancy, bookings earn $34,065 after the host fee and cleaner, or $54,944 at 100%
$30,037 / $54,94454.7% occupancy
How do I find the break-even nightly rate?
Hold your occupancy and solve for the rate at which Airbnb net equals the tenant net. On the example inputs it is $158.94 a night at 62% occupancy.
Each extra dollar of nightly rate adds the booked nights, less the host fee on them, to net. That makes the answer a straight-line solve rather than a guess.
If your rate is above the break-even, Airbnb is ahead at that occupancy.
Break-even rate at 62% occupancy
Each $1 of rate adds 226.3 nights x (1 - 15.5%)$191.22 to net
With a rate of $0, cleaning fees after the host fee less the cleaner leave -$356
($30,037 + $356) / $191.22$158.94 a night
Which costs does only one plan carry?
Airbnb carries the host fee, cleaners, utilities, supplies, furnishing and extra insurance. A tenant lease carries empty weeks and maintenance.
Enter each as its own input so you can see which one moves the answer. Furnishing is the cost of furniture and linens spread over the months they last, because a tenant usually brings their own.
If a manager runs either plan, enter its fee on that side only.
Does the host fee model change the answer?
Yes. On the split fee, Airbnb takes 3% from the host instead of 15.5%, and the guest pays the rest on top.
At the same nightly rate and occupancy the split fee leaves you more. But the guest's total price is higher, so occupancy may be lower than it was on the host-only fee.
Run both and check that the occupancy you enter is one you can still reach.
Same inputs on the split fee
Subtotal $47,200 x 3%$1,416 host fee, instead of $7,316
Enter the rate and occupancy you can support from comparable listings, and a rent quote or a comparable lease.
2
When an offer arrives
Change the rent and read the break-even occupancy. If you cannot reach it, take the tenant.
3
When you want to check it
After a few months, compare your real occupancy and net per property in MagicBNB with the break-even you worked out here.
Terms on this page
Break-even occupancy
The Airbnb occupancy at which Airbnb and a tenant net the same.
Break-even nightly rate
The nightly rate at which they net the same, at your occupancy.
Shared costs
Costs you pay either way, such as the mortgage, property tax and a standard insurance policy.
Host-only fee
Airbnb's single fee charged to the host, 15.5% for most hosts.
Split fee
Airbnb's fee shared between host and guest, with 3% on the host side.
Empty weeks
Weeks between tenants in a year when no rent comes in.
Questions
Is Airbnb or long-term rental more profitable?
Whichever has the higher net after its own costs. On the example inputs, Airbnb nets $6,705 a year against $2,677 from a tenant. At 45% occupancy the same property nets a loss on Airbnb and the tenant is ahead by $5,313. The answer moves with your occupancy, rate and rent.
What occupancy does Airbnb need to beat a long-term tenant?
The break-even occupancy, which the calculator solves for. It is the occupancy at which Airbnb net equals the tenant net. On the example inputs it is 54.7%. With a tenant paying $2,800 instead of $2,200 it rises to 67.0%, because the Airbnb side has more to beat.
Does the Airbnb host fee model change the result?
Yes. The host-only fee is 15.5% of the nightly price plus the cleaning fee. The split fee takes 3% from the host and charges the guest the rest. On the example inputs the split fee lifts Airbnb net from $6,705 to $12,605 a year, but the guest pays more, so check your demand holds.
Which costs does Airbnb carry that a long-term rental does not?
The Airbnb host fee, a cleaner for every stay, utilities and internet, supplies, furnishing spread over its life, and extra insurance for short stays. A tenant lease instead carries empty weeks between tenants and maintenance. Both enter the calculator as inputs you can change.
Do my mortgage and property tax change which is better?
They change both nets, but not the difference or the break-evens. You pay them either way. On the example inputs, removing $1,750 a month of shared costs lifts both nets by $21,000 a year and the gap stays at $4,028.
How is the break-even nightly rate worked out?
Holding your occupancy, it is the nightly rate at which Airbnb net equals the tenant net. Airbnb net rises in a straight line with the rate, so the calculator solves it exactly. On the example inputs it is $158.94 a night at 62% occupancy.
Does the comparison include income tax or local rules?
No. The figures are pre-tax operating results, and mortgage principal and depreciation are not modelled. Rules on short-term and long-term rentals, permits and licences differ by place, so check yours before you choose. The tax calculator covers the income side.
Should I include furnishing in the Airbnb costs?
Yes, if you would not buy the furniture and linens for a tenant. Enter their cost divided by the months they last. On the example inputs furnishing is $150 a month, or $1,800 a year of the Airbnb side's costs.
How many empty weeks should I enter for a tenant?
Use your own history or a manager's quote. Each empty week costs one fifty-second of a year's rent. On the example $2,200 rent that is $507.69 a week, and the three weeks entered cost $1,523 a year.
How much does the cleaning fee matter?
A lot. On the example inputs, setting the cleaning fee to $0 drops Airbnb net from $6,705 to $1,241 a year, and the tenant is then ahead by $1,436. Enter the fee you really charge per stay.
Do longer stays help the Airbnb side?
A little, when the cleaning fee does not fully cover the cleaner. On the example inputs, moving the average stay from 2 nights to 7 nights moves Airbnb net from $6,438 to $6,882 a year.
This calculator compares two options you describe. MagicBNB's Tree-of-Thoughts (multi-scenario) analysis lays out scenarios side by side on revenue, ROI timeline and risk, then recommends one with its reasoning.
Two more places this shows up in MagicBNB
Listings tableNet revenue and margin per property, so you can see which doors earn more than a lease would.
Property DetailMonth-by-month revenue per property with last year beside it, to check the occupancy you assumed.
This is the quick look at one property. MagicBNB runs the same numbers in depth and in real time, property by property, with a YoY comparison on every view.